Crimson Desert | Critical Consensus

Initially conceived as a prequel to Pearl Abyss’ blockbuster Black Desert On-line franchise, Crimson Desert was spun off into its personal sport early in growth. Since its 2020 reveal, the sport has attracted an excessive amount of pleasure and going into 2026, is without doubt one of the most-anticipated releases of the yr.

Out of the gate, Crimson Desert boasts a score of 78 on Metacritic, reflecting broadly constructive sentiment in the direction of the sport but additionally highlighting some frustrations critics have had whereas taking part in the title.

General, reviewers appear to benefit from the sport’s fight and world, whereas lamenting the sheer systemic complexity and a scarcity of polish within the characters and story.

Story woes

Writing for Eurogamer, Lewis Gordon gave the eagerly-awaited title 3/5 stars, saying that whereas the sport is clearly “technically proficient” and has “killer fight”, “its characters and story are fatally undercooked”.

Criticisms of the sport’s story are echoed in PC Gamer’s review, the place Mollie Taylor writes that this narrative is “not precisely riveting”, one thing that she believes is partly resulting from Pearl Abyss’ heritage as an MMO developer.

“It is the style’s actual model of serviceably bland and nonsensical,” Taylor wrote. “There is no clear timeline of occasions, and I am by no means positive of any character’s motivations, even my very own.”

“I do know Crimson Desert’s predominant story can do higher, as a result of all of the attraction it is lacking could be present in its aspect quests”

Mollie Taylor, PC Gamer

She continued: “What’s extra irritating is that I do know Crimson Desert’s predominant story can do higher, as a result of all of the attraction it is lacking could be present in its aspect quests.”

VG247’s guides editor James Billcliffe sums up the battle between Crimson Desert’s good and unhealthy relatively succinctly in his 3/5 star overview.

“So I’ve stated the story doesn’t make any sense and it’s a chore to play, but additionally that Crimson Desert may very well be among the finest video games of the technology? What’s up with that?”

He continued, saying that the size of Crimson Desert’s world is “unbelievable, genuinely wonderful”, happening to explain witnessing a sundown within the RPG as “one of the crucial visually breathtaking scenes in latest reminiscence”.

IGN’s Travis Northup stated in his review-in-progress that the open world is “completely beautiful”, including that “it seems like something is feasible”.

The open world is a side that the majority critics appear to be enamoured with. GameSpot’s Richard Wakeling wrote in his 7/10 overview of Crimson Desert that he “cannot overstate how unbelievable” this facet of the sport is.

“There have been just a few instances the place I picked a course and easily explored for hours on finish, only for the sake of it,” he stated.

“It takes a particular form of open world for me to do that, and Crimson Desert’s is strictly that.”

Preventing likelihood

One other space of Crimson Desert that has attracted near-unanimous reward is its fight, which PC Gamer’s Taylor stated “completely rips”.

“It felt like each time I pressed buttons in a barely completely different order, Crimson Desert had bespoke animations or motion chains for it,” she wrote.

Billcliffe provides that fight is “unassumingly deep” and that he ended up craving “bigger battles” the place you’ll be able to combat hordes of enemies.

GameSpot’s Wakeling, in the meantime, described the fight as “wonderful”.

“[Protagonist] Kliff hits with a visceral ferocity that is instantly satisfying,” he wrote. “As you become familiar along with his versatile type of fight, the extra fluid he turns into as you begin chaining collectively combos, thrusting his sword ahead earlier than leaping right into a dropkick that ends together with your downed opponent skewered on the tip of your blade. Enemies generally tend to swarm in massive numbers, and so they do not wait their flip, forcing you to parry and dodge incoming blows as you reposition for one more barrage of assaults.”

Michael Hoglund over at Windows Central stated in his 4.5/5 overview that the choices out there to you in relation to fight are large, however they “by no means felt overwhelmed or underwhelmed”

“Fight is simply pure, unadulterated enjoyable that by no means actually grows tiresome,” he wrote. “Whether or not it is towards the better NPCs that you just’ve out-levelled, or the terrifyingly sturdy armies of Demenis, your relatively violent neighbour, Crimson Desert’s fight is so fluid, the top result’s all the time satisfying.”

Reward for this facet is just not unanimous: IGN’s Northup described the fight as “uneven” and laments that encounters “go on method too lengthy”.

Systematic chaos

GameSpot’s Wakeling says that at a macro degree, Crimson Desert is an extremely spectacular expertise, however provides that “it is on a smaller scale the place cracks start to point out”, reminiscent of frustrations round stock administration and therapeutic. He says that being pulled away from fight and exploration to handle your stock is “disappointing” in its frequency.

VG247’s overview shared related frustrations, describing them as “baffling UI choices”.

“Not like each different sport, enemies do not have a viewable stock so that you want area for all the pieces they’re carrying earlier than you’ll be able to loot them, however you can also’t see what you are selecting up earlier than it is added to your bag,” Billcliffe stated. “That means you need to seize every bit of junk earlier than instantly throwing it away.”

Home windows Central’s Hoglund additionally factors out that whereas the sport has a wealth of choices in relation to issues to do, reminiscent of mini video games, “that cataclysmic variety of actions can generally backfire”, saying that they usually lack depth or polish.

Watch on YouTube

“That ‘on occasion’ of coming throughout unnecessary or pointless actions did not actually bolster my love of Crimson Desert’s open world,” he stated. “As a substitute, it was a damaging on the expertise, making the sum of the entire components really feel disconnected from the sport.”

The sheer variety of issues to do additionally makes progress gradual when taking part in the sport. Eurogamer’s Gordon described the sport as “saggy” and having an “audacious pitch”.

“The builders at Pearl Abyss have tried to summon a world of inexhaustible issues to do,” he stated. “That is the promise of a life-dominating MMORPG transposed to a glittering single-player expertise which may final anyplace between 50 to 100 hours (and certain much more relying on playstyle and talent). Even previous hour 15, I used to be nonetheless being fed tutorial screens.”

“Regardless of these sore spots, Crimson Desert is a steadily thrilling sport, elevated by an open world nicely value exploring and hard-hitting fight”

Richard Wakeling, Gamespot

For PC Gamer’s Taylor, this huge variety of techniques and mini video games is a blended bag.

“It is an infinite path of gumdrops, one the place each new step incorporates a brand new sugary deal with for me to pop into my mouth,” she stated. “Not all these techniques are made equal.”

Regardless of his frustrations with Crimson Desert, Wakeling is optimistic that Pearl Abyss can handle them going ahead.

“The excellent news is that points like these could be rectified with just a few tweaks,” he stated.

“Whether or not that occurs or not stays to be seen, and the standard of quests and blunted narrative are a lot more durable shortcomings to repair. But regardless of these sore spots, Crimson Desert is a steadily thrilling sport, elevated by an open world nicely value exploring and hard-hitting fight that delights with its depth and emphasis on participant expression.”