Bloodborne is celebrating its 10-year anniversary at this time, March 24, 2025. Under, we reexamine the divisive Chalice Dungeons, which have aged extra gracefully in mild of Elden Ring.
Ten years after launch, it is honest to say that Bloodborne is taken into account one of many biggest PlayStation video games of all time. From its nightmarish late-gate dreamscapes to its haunting enemy design, each aspect of its Lovecraftian world has been dissected and torn aside by 1000’s of fawning YouTube movies. Nonetheless, there’s one side of Bloodborne that is thought-about underwhelming by nearly everybody: its Chalice Dungeons, a complete ecosystem of non-obligatory procedurally generated content material that some gamers do not even contact.
And whereas the Chalice Dungeons definitely do have their issues, on stability, they’re an progressive addition to the Souls system that prefigured the sprawling facet catacombs and underground gaols of Elden Ring. Contemplating that each one of us Yharnamites are nonetheless ready for a hypothetical Bloodborne 2 with bated breath all these years later, maybe it is time for us to revisit this underappreciated side of the sport with recent eyes. We will strategy it not as merely one thing that is good or unhealthy, however as a system that merely supplies extra Bloodborne to these of us who nonetheless have not had our fill greater than a decade later.
For these needing a refresher, Bloodborne’s Chalice Dungeons are randomly generated labyrinths meant to characterize the cursed underground beneath the town of Yharnam. To entry your first, it’s essential to slay the non-obligatory boss Blood-Starved Beast in Outdated Yharnam, which drops the Pthumeru Chalice as a reward. From there, you gather extra ritual supplies and chalices by defeating bosses throughout the confines of those dungeons. You slowly work your means into more difficult corridors till you are combating even harder variations of already-stout foes you struggled with in the principle marketing campaign.
You do not have to look far to seek out folks citing Chalice Dungeons as certainly one of Bloodborne’s solely flaws. Just like the Covenants system in Darkish Souls 1, whenever you study these randomized dungeons beneath a microscope, you would possibly surprise if From Software program wished to spend a bit extra time refining their system.
These dungeons are usually darkish, cramped, and complicated in structure, and it might typically be tough to determine the precise path by means of, and never all the time in a satisfying means. Maybe the most important downside with Chalice Dungeons is that your primary reward for finishing them is… extra Chalice Dungeons, particularly early on. The baroque treasure rooms and big chests you get for beating these bosses develop into a bit underwhelming whenever you notice that they have an inclination to drop the identical ritual supplies it’s good to advance additional down every chalice spoke. When you think about that the majority gamers trudging their means by means of these dungeons are doubtless simply doing it to get the Platinum Trophy, it is comprehensible that they could complain about their shortcomings.
Nevertheless, removed from only a vestigial a part of the sport, Bloodborne’s Chalice Dungeons are surprisingly refined when considered from a broader perspective. For these of us who’ve performed our favourite Lovecraftian motion recreation dozens of instances, these randomized bits of content material have the potential to shock and problem you. A few of Bloodborne’s finest and most memorable boss fights require you to delve into the Chalice Dungeons, together with Watchdog of the Outdated Lords, Bloodletting Beast, Abhorrent Beast, and, after all, the Pthumerian Queen. Those that delight within the recreation’s lore will discover a lot to dig into down right here, from the merchandise descriptions of unusual drops to unseen interactions between lesser-known enemies.
The mobs that you simply discover within the higher-level dungeons are additionally fairly powerful at instances, and so they’re able to tearing even fairly skilled gamers aside, particularly should you aren’t cautious about pulling them one after the other. Foes that by no means put up even a distant problem within the base recreation can develop into mighty killers in a dice-rolled dungeon, and also you would possibly even run into uncommon variants that few have ever seen, together with bosses roaming round as common enemies. Once you add within the non-obligatory Fetid, Rotten, Cursed, and Sinister Rites, which dial up the problem even further–especially Cursed, because it halves your health–these labyrinths have the potential to push you to your restrict.
One of many key causes that Chalice Dungeons stay underappreciated even at this time is that it may be obscure find out how to get probably the most out of them with out consulting online guides. The key factor to know is that the bottom dungeons it’s essential to full to get to the Pthumerian Queen are static, and customarily don’t characteristic the copious rewards you could get from Depth 5 Chalices, that are the toughest within the recreation. As a way to get that loot, it’s essential to receive the Root Chalices from finishing the static content material and use them to randomly generate new dungeons.
Root Chalice Dungeons include the very best loot in Bloodborne, together with Misplaced and Uncanny variations of weapons (which are sometimes wanted for optimum builds), top-line Caryll Runes, highly effective Blood Gems, and high-end ore for upgrading weapons, together with the all-important Blood Rock. All of those add as much as huge variations in your character’s energy degree. You too can use the “glyph codes” generated by the Bloodborne neighborhood to enter situations which can be assured to drop the loot you want, however the place’s the enjoyable in that? These difficult bits of content material require each little bit of talent and finesse that you have gathered out of your time as a Hunter, and in the event that they get too intense, they provide a possibility to co-op together with your friends–a rarity within the recreation.
Bloodborne is typically dinged by followers for not providing sufficient content material or replayability when in comparison with the Souls sequence. In the event you’re prepared to vary your perspective and undertake a dungeon-diving angle, Bloodborne’s Chalice Dungeons provide reams of content material to dig by means of: sufficient to rival even Elden Ring. It is curious that From Software program has but to revisit this technique within the 10 years for the reason that recreation’s launch, however on condition that the upcoming Elden Ring: Nightreign has adopted a roguelike construction, maybe it is the unlikely progeny of Bloodborne’s most underappreciated system.
So the following time you revisit Bloodborne and also you groan on the considered revisiting the Chalice Dungeons, contemplate giving them an opportunity. Why not pour a couple of hours into these random seeds for an opportunity to create your strongest construct ever? Whereas they can not evaluate to the sport’s precise ranges, they’re an attention-grabbing experiment that present that additional drip feed of content material for a recreation that also hasn’t obtained the sequel it so richly deserves. Till then, these dice-rolled corridors are the very best we have got.
Spec Ops: The Line Delisting Reason Revealed, Director Comments On Removal